← Back to RehomingREHOMING GUIDE

How to Rehome a American Shorthair

Needing to rehome an American Shorthair does not make you a bad owner. This is the classic sturdy family cat: easygoing, quietly affectionate, good with children and respectful dogs, and famously low-drama. Cats like that almost never lose a home over behaviour; they lose it to a move, a landlord, an allergy, a household change. One wrinkle is unique to this breed: many cats called American Shorthairs in Canada are actually domestic shorthairs, and it is worth knowing which you have before you write the listing. This guide covers both, plus a free vetted listing on LocalPetFinder.

10 min read · Updated June 16, 2026
Author: LocalPetFinder Team

The short answer

Rehoming an American Shorthair is a responsible choice, and the easygoing family-cat profile places well across Canada. List your cat free on LocalPetFinder, where it appears alongside rescue cats and vetted adopters reach you through a verified form. If a move is forcing the decision, our moving guide covers the timeline and the keep-the-cat options first. One quick identity check before you write anything: a true American Shorthair is a pedigreed breed with registration papers. If your cat is a wonderful shorthaired cat without papers, that is a domestic shorthair, and our domestic shorthair guide is written for exactly that cat. Either way, the advice below holds.

Rehome your cat on LocalPetFinder, free

List your cat at no cost. They stay home until the right family is found, you screen adopters through a verified contact form, and you choose who adopts. Reviewed within 24 to 48 hours.

A American Shorthair at home in Canada, waiting for a responsible rehoming match
Rehoming responsibly keeps your American Shorthair out of an overcrowded shelter and helps you find the right next home.

Why American Shorthairs end up needing a new home

The Cat Fanciers' Association describes a gentle, adaptable, even-tempered companion bred down from working cats, and that temperament is almost never the surrender story. The recurring reasons:

  • Moving. The big one. An adaptable family cat inherits its family's housing story, and Canadian rental turnover, no-pets clauses, and job relocations write most of it. If a move is forcing your decision, our guide to rehoming because of a move covers the timeline and the options, including keeping the cat if you can.
  • Allergies and new babies. The breed's family-friendliness means it lives in exactly the households where both arrive.
  • An older owner's circumstances. A calm, undemanding cat suits quiet households, so illness and moves into care account for a steady share of rehomings.
  • Weight and vet-cost creep. American Shorthairs are stocky, food-motivated, and prone to gaining weight, and some households rehome when a vet starts talking about diets and dental work.

Notice what is missing: behaviour problems. An American Shorthair listing is one of the easiest honest listings you will ever write, and the placement work is matching, not marketing.

Is your cat an American Shorthair or a domestic shorthair?

Here is the distinction, briefly, because it shapes the listing. The American Shorthair is a pedigreed breed recognized by CFA and TICA, with registration papers, documented lineage, and a breeder behind it. A domestic shorthair is any shorthaired cat of the general population, which is most cats in Canada, including many that look exactly like the silver classic tabby on the breed posters.

Why it matters a little: if your cat has papers, say so and include them in the handover, and check the purchase contract, because reputable Canadian breeders often include a take-back clause and one phone call may solve the whole problem. If your cat has no papers, describe her as a shorthaired cat and never invent a pedigree to justify a fee; the temperament sells itself, and honesty is the whole foundation of a placement that lasts.

Why it matters less than you might fear: the care, the screening, and the kind of home that suits the cat are identical either way. If yours is a domestic shorthair, our domestic shorthair guide is the fuller version of this conversation, written for the everycat that most Canadian cats are.

Screening and disclosure for a classic family cat

An American Shorthair suits more homes than most breeds in this series, which makes screening pleasantly simple. Three checks matter most.

1. Match the household honestly. This is a companionable cat that likes being around its people without living on them. Families with gentle children, respectful dogs, and ordinary routines are the breed's natural habitat. Say in the listing what your cat actually does on a normal evening, in specifics, not adjectives.

2. Indoor-only, settled before it starts. An easygoing, trusting cat has no more street sense than a glamorous one. Our Ragdoll guide covers the indoor-only screening conversation in depth, and it applies here too.

3. Disclose the file. Hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM) is documented in the breed, so share any murmur a vet has mentioned, any screening results, breeder paperwork, and the complete records. Our Maine Coon guide covers HCM disclosure in depth, and the same hand-over-the-file approach applies. State the current weight and your vet's target, because the breed's stocky build hides gain, and describe litter habits and behaviour with kids, dogs, and other cats from what you have actually seen.

American Shorthair rescues and where to ask

Here is the honest picture: there is no American-Shorthair-specific rescue based in Canada we can currently verify as active and taking owner surrenders. The practical paths are all-breed cat rescues and humane societies in your province, which take easygoing family cats readily, and a direct vetted listing with the honest write-up described above. If your cat is registered and came from a breeder, check the purchase contract first; take-back clauses are common among reputable Canadian breeders.

Should you charge a rehoming fee?

Charge a real rehoming fee. A registered American Shorthair costs real money from a breeder, and even without papers a healthy, sweet-tempered adult deserves the screening value a fee provides. A fee in the low hundreds for a healthy adult is normal in Canada (this is a directional range, not a fixed rule), paired with a vet reference and a meeting at your home or theirs, never a parking lot, with the cat spayed or neutered before handover. Donate the fee to a cat rescue afterward if you would rather not keep it.

How LocalPetFinder rehoming works

  1. Submit a free listing at /rehome/submit. Photos, age, breed, spay or neuter status, compatibility, an honest behavioural profile, your reason for rehoming, and a fee. The form takes about 5 minutes and your cat never leaves your home.
  2. We review it for completeness and basic safety, usually within 24 to 48 hours, then it goes live.
  3. Your American Shorthair appears alongside rescue cats on the American Shorthair listings and the main adoption pages, marked “Owner Rehoming.” Your email stays private.
  4. You screen and choose. Vetted adopters reach you through a verified contact form. You decide who to respond to, who to meet, and who gets the cat.

Ready to rehome your American Shorthair responsibly?

List your American Shorthair on LocalPetFinder for free. Your listing appears next to rescue cats, you control the screening, and we never share your email publicly.

Start Your Free Listing →

Anti-scam rules (read every line)

  • Never list as “free to good home.” A fair fee is the single best filter against flippers and bad-faith adopters.
  • Insist on a meet-and-greet, ideally at the adopter's home. Anyone who refuses a home check is hiding their living situation.
  • Be suspicious of anyone offering more than your fee, or pushing for a fast, no-questions handover.
  • Get a written agreement and a vet reference, transfer the microchip registration, and prefer e-transfer over cash for a paper trail.

Frequently asked questions

Are American Shorthairs hard to rehome?
No. A calm, sturdy, family-friendly cat is one of the most broadly appealing profiles in Canadian rehoming, and a healthy adult with honest photos and a fair fee typically places in two to five weeks. The work is matching rather than marketing: screen for an ordinary, stable household and an indoor-only commitment, and the placement tends to stick.
How do I know if my cat is a real American Shorthair?
Papers. A true American Shorthair comes with registration from CFA or TICA and a breeder behind it. Without papers, your cat is a domestic shorthair, however perfectly she matches the breed photos, and that changes nothing about her value or her placement. Describe what you actually have, never invent a pedigree to justify a fee, and if she is a domestic shorthair, our domestic shorthair guide is written for exactly her.
I am rehoming because of a move. Is that a legitimate reason?
Yes, and it is the most common reason this kind of cat changes homes. Check the keep-the-cat options first: our moving guide covers negotiating with landlords, the real timeline, and when the move genuinely wins. If it does, say so plainly in the listing. Adopters read a moving rehoming as circumstances, not a problem cat, and an easygoing cat with a clean story places quickly.
What health issues do I have to disclose?
Share what you actually have: the complete vet records, any heart murmur or HCM screening results (hypertrophic cardiomyopathy is documented in the breed), any breeder paperwork, and the current weight with your vet's target, since American Shorthairs gain weight easily and the stocky build hides it. You are not diagnosing anything. Hand over the file, name your vet, and the new home plans from there.
Will my American Shorthair cope with being rehomed?
This breed copes better than most. Adaptability is its defining trait, and an even-tempered cat that transfers to a calm household with familiar bedding, the routine written down, and a quiet first fortnight typically settles within weeks. The steadiness that made her easy to live with makes her easy to place, and easy to settle.
Is there an American Shorthair rescue in Canada that will take my cat?
Not one we can verify as active and taking owner surrenders. All-breed cat rescues and humane societies across Canada accept family-friendly shorthairs readily, and a screened direct rehoming through LocalPetFinder is the other realistic path. If the cat is registered, call the breeder first; take-back clauses are common in this breed.
How long does it take to rehome an American Shorthair?
For a healthy adult with good photos and an honest listing, two to five weeks is typical. Seniors take somewhat longer but suit the quiet households that love this breed's calm. Use the time to verify the vet reference and the indoor-only commitment rather than accepting the fastest applicant; on any healthy, attractive cat, speed is the reseller's signature.

Sources

Related guides

Rehoming guides for other cat breeds